Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content

Review rules

​​PROCEDURE F​OR REVIEWING​

        ​
      ​Scientific and technical journal "Seismic technologies" is a peer-review journal. Reviewing procedure is the following:

  1. Members of the editorial board review all incoming manuscripts checking if they fit the scope of the journal. Final decision on accepting manuscripts for review is made by the editor-in-chief.
  2. The editor-in-chief forwards selected papers for further consideration to the scientific editor who is a member of the editorial board.
  3. Members of the editorial board or other distinguished experts with scientific degree and expertise in corresponding area are invited to review the manuscript. Each reviewer has scientific publications on paper subject during the last three years.
  4. Editorial board directs to the authors the reviews of their papers.
  5. Authors provide a written response to the comments and recommendations of the reviewers with explanation of agreeing or disagreeing with their position.   
  6. In consideration of the review, the answer of the author and science editor opinion the Editor-in-chief makes the decision to publish or to reject the paper.
  7. The paper is rejected when negative opinions by the reviewer, the science editor and the Editor-in-chief coincide.
  8. Upon consideration, the editorial staff notifies the author of the acceptance for publication or motivated rejection.
  9.  Reviews of submitted manuscripts are stored for 5 years.
  10. The editorial board agrees to send copies of the reviews to the Ministry of Education and Science of the Russian Federation when requested.